While some people might be suspicious of this analogy, I think the arXiv and Craigslist have a lot in common; both took a service previously only available through an expensive print intermediary, and instead made it freely available on the web.
But there’s one point where the analogy breaks down: the aggressiveness with which they have expanded. Craigslist started out only in San Francisco, but has since opened a bewildering number of local sites. Of course, at the time, most them were very sparsely used at first, since people in those cities had never heard of Craigslist. But relatively quickly, the ones all over the US took off (for a sense of which are getting used, I think best of craigslist is an excellent way to get a (highly NSFW) cross-section). I think some of the UK ones are also getting some use, though there are also dozens of mostly empty Craigslist sites for random foreign cities like Seoul or Buenos Aires. However, when the demand gets in place for such sites, Craigslist will be there, and who’s to say where and when it will happen first. After all, it was very little trouble for craigslist to set up the foreign sites, having already created the US ones.
Similarly, the arXiv has a model which scales brilliantly, and in the time that Craigslist has gone from an SF-only site to covering 500 cities around the world, the arXiv has…added sections in Quantitative Biology and Quantitative Finance. I don’t want to be too hard on the arXiv. I mean, they do an incredible service to the mathematics and physics communities, but I don’t understand why they’ve taken such a restrictive view of their possibilities. Maybe there’s some serious obstruction I’m not seeing, but I’d like to know what it is.
I mean, why not an arXiv for economics? For literature? For history? My understanding is that most other disciplines don’t have a centralized preprint server (this experience is most based on my dating of grad students in other disciplines, so it’s rather, ahem, anecdotal), so why isn’t the arXiv at least providing the opportunity? Maybe they wouldn’t be used much at first, but what’s the harm in trying?